Experience with selling Carbon Emission Reduction for Small Hydro Power Plants
Brascan Energética's pioneering experience obtaining and commercializing Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) under the Clean Development Mechanism for 11 small hydro power plants in Brazil.
Experience with selling Carbon Emission Reduction for Small Hydro Power Plants
By Antonio Fonseca dos Santos and Julien Dominic Publio Dias — Brascan Energética S.A., for Carbonnews
Introduction
The Earth's atmosphere acts as a filter for solar rays; approximately half of the visible light and ultraviolet radiation given off by the sun is either absorbed by the various atmospheric layers or reflected back into space. The greenhouse effect results from the atmospheric trapping of infrared radiation — a natural phenomenon without which the Earth would be too cold for humans. When carbon-based fossil fuels are burned, greenhouse gases (GHG) such as carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide are emitted, thickening the layer of greenhouse gases and gradually increasing the Earth's temperature, now known as global climate change.
Kyoto Protocol and Clean Development Mechanism
The Kyoto Protocol, approved in 1997, establishes conditions for implementation of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). It stipulates which actions should be taken by nations to combat global climate change and establishes as a main goal, to be achieved in 2012, the emission reduction of GHG by an average of 5.2% of the values recorded in 1990 for industrialized countries.
To assist the parties to achieve their GHG emission reduction targets, the Protocol defines three innovative "flexibility mechanisms": the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), Joint Implementation (JI) and Emissions Trading. CDM is the only one in which the participation of developing countries is voluntary. CDM allowed the certification of small hydro power plants, on the grounds that such projects will reduce GHG emissions and the commercialization of the Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) so they can be used by developed countries to meet their emission reduction targets.
Brascan Energética's Experience
Brascan Energética S.A. is the Brazilian subsidiary of Brookfield Power, an independent power producer constructing and operating small hydro power plants in Brazil (those with less than 30MW of installed capacity and reservoirs with less than three square kilometres of surface area). CDM and CERs are already a reality for Brascan Energética. Last April, the company's 11 small hydro power plants successfully transferred 487,000 tCO2 to buyers. This transference was possible through the signature of 06 Emission Reduction Purchase Agreements (ERPA).
Brascan Energética had to overcome various hurdles to register the projects at the CDM Executive Board and issue the CERs. When the company initiated the process back in 2003, the Kyoto Protocol was not yet operational (this occurred only in February 2005, when Russia ratified the Protocol). Among the barriers faced was the baseline methodology — at the time, no baseline methodology was available for SHPPs in Brazil. Brascan, together with its adviser, developed the first baseline methodology for SHPPs in Brazil, known as the Passo do Meio Methodology.
The most important step was the rationale for additionality: Brascan had to prove that operation of the 11 renewable energy projects would avoid the emission of CO2. The company, together with adviser Ecoinvest, had to create a huge database incorporating all information regarding energy demand and the energy source divided between clean and carbon intensive. The entire process took almost 4 years from the development of the Project Idea Note (PIN) to the issuance of the CERs and the invoice to the buyer.
Lessons Learned
Brascan Energética's experience clearly illustrates that pioneering any process has a high price. The demands of developing a methodology, establishing procedures for validation and gathering data, accounted for the length of time — almost four years — needed for the entire process.
As a development strategy, any developer has to consider the possibility of obtaining CERs for small hydro power plants as a means of adding economic value to the projects. Sometimes this added value can be the difference between projects that are feasible and those that are not. It is also important to try to establish and develop the ERPA in parallel with the certification process, so that valuable time is saved once the CERs are issued.
About the Authors: Antonio Fonseca dos Santos — M.Sc. Hydrology, Colorado State University, Environment and Sustainability Manager at Brascan Brasil Corporation. Julien Dominic Publio Dias — Certificate in Finance with Mathematics, Birkbeck College, University of London, Finance Manager at Brascan Energética S.A.